India's search for a dependable off-spinner following Ravichandran Ashwin's departure has become an important talking point ahead of the Test series against New Zealand. Former New Zealand spinner Dipak Patel believes the shortage is surprising, particularly given India's long association with high-quality spin bowling.
He also sees a wider problem in modern cricket, where off-spinners have fewer opportunities in T20 matches and captains appear increasingly reluctant to use them. His assessment raises questions about how the role has changed and whether teams are doing enough to develop the next generation.
Ashwin's success across formats makes the search for a successor particularly challenging. Patel considers him the last specialist off-spinner to achieve significant success in T20 cricket, while acknowledging that the discipline remains relevant in Test matches and has produced occasional results in one-day internationals.
Ashwin's statistics illustrate why his absence is significant. He represented India in 65 T20 internationals, taking 72 wickets while maintaining an economy rate below seven runs per over. His Indian Premier League career also ended with an impressive record of 187 wickets from 221 appearances across five teams.
Those figures demonstrate that Ashwin could contribute in a format where batters regularly look to attack spinners. His ability to control scoring while creating opportunities for wickets made him a valuable option for different teams. Replacing that combination requires more than finding someone who bowls off-spin; a successor must also develop the control, tactical understanding, and confidence to perform against aggressive batting.
Patel believes the reduced presence of off-spinners in T20 cricket cannot be explained entirely by improvements in batting. He also points to the decisions made by captains, arguing that the way a spinner is used can influence whether the bowler receives opportunities to establish a role.
Modern batters are generally more prepared to attack spin, using a wider selection of shots and looking for scoring options even when bowlers maintain disciplined lines. That development makes the job more demanding, particularly when an off-spinner is introduced during a period when the opposition is targeting boundaries.
However, Patel argues that captains should not become overly cautious. A bowler's effectiveness can depend on the conditions, field placements, match situation, and the confidence shown by the team management. If captains avoid using off-spinners whenever batters appear aggressive, opportunities for young players to develop at the highest level may become limited.
Another factor highlighted by Patel is the introduction of the Decision Review System. He believes DRS has influenced how batters approach spin bowling, particularly when deciding whether to use their pads as protection. Before reviews became a major part of the game, batters could sometimes use their pads deliberately to prevent the ball from reaching the stumps. With the possibility of an lbw decision being reviewed, that approach carries greater risk.
As a result, batters have had to adjust their defensive methods and become more proactive in responding to deliveries. Patel sees this change as one reason modern players have become more effective against spin. For off-spinners, the adjustment matters because their success often depends on creating uncertainty through changes in flight, turn, and line. When batters are more willing to play shots rather than rely on their pads, bowlers must work harder to create mistakes.
While discussing the challenges facing spin bowling, Patel also praised New Zealand Test captain Tom Latham for the way he has handled his available options. Latham has managed both Mitchell Santner and Ajaz Patel, showing an understanding of how different spinners can be used within a team strategy.
However, Patel is uncertain whether New Zealand will select a specialist spinner for the upcoming series. Conditions at home may influence that decision, and he does not expect the pitches to provide substantial assistance to slow bowlers.
Patel expects the contest between India and New Zealand to depend heavily on how effectively each batting lineup handles the opposition's pace attack. Both teams have strong fast-bowling resources, and the ability to negotiate difficult spells could become a decisive factor.
New Zealand's seamers have the advantage of greater familiarity with local conditions. Indian batters, meanwhile, will need to adjust to the movement and challenges presented by playing away from home. Patel also recognizes the emergence of quality seamers and leg-spinners in India's white-ball cricket. Those developments provide encouraging signs for the country's bowling depth, even as the search for a specialist off-spinner continues.
India's difficulty in developing another dependable off-spinner after Ashwin reflects several changes in modern cricket. As India prepares to face New Zealand, the immediate contest may be shaped more by the two pace attacks, but the longer-term question remains: can India produce an off-spinner capable of making the same kind of impact Ashwin achieved?